Skip to content
DT Nova

Does creatine break a fast?

Does creatine break a fast? Plain creatine monohydrate is unlikely to break an intermittent fast, because it is not a food and a typical 3 to 5 gram dose adds no meaningful calories. The catch is what comes with it. Flavored powders, pre-workouts and creatine gummies can contain sugar and carbohydrate, and those do break a fast.

So the answer depends on what is on your label. We looked for a study that tested creatine during fasting and did not find one, so this page is reasoning from the rule and the label. It is not a measured result. By the DT Nova team, the people behind FastTrack.

Medical note: This is general information, not advice for you. Ask a clinician before fasting if you are pregnant or breastfeeding, or have diabetes. The same goes for medication that must be taken with food, or a history of an eating disorder. If your fast is for a lab test, the instructions from whoever ordered the test override this page.

Creatine products: does each one break a fast?

Check the Supplement Facts panel on your own tub
ProductWhat to look forStrict fast
Plain creatine monohydrate, unflavoredCreatine only, no calories listedFine under the calorie rule
Creatine HCl capsulesCheck the capsule and any fillersUsually fine, check the label
Flavored creatine powderSweeteners, maybe sugarCheck for calories and sweeteners
Creatine gummiesUsually contain sugar or sugar alcoholsLikely breaks it
Pre-workout with creatineOften sugars, amino acids, sweetenersCheck the label, often breaks it
Creatine mixed in juice or a shakeThe juice or shake is the caloriesBreaks it

The rule we are applying

Cleveland Clinic says: "To maintain a fasting state, you must not consume any foods or drinks with calories." That is why the label decides it. Plain creatine does not add calories that you would need to count, so it passes. Add sugar, and it does not.

Reading three labels at 7:00 am
  • Tub A, unflavored: creatine monohydrate 5 g, no calories listed. Passes a strict fast.
  • Tub B, fruit punch: 5 g creatine, 15 calories, 3 g carbohydrate. Breaks a strict fast.
  • Tub C, zero sugar, sweetened with sucralose: 0 calories on the label. A gray area, see below.

The sweetener problem

A flavored powder that says zero sugar may still have sweeteners. Cleveland Clinic advises: "Avoid or limit artificial sweeteners", and says that sweeteners "like saccharin, aspartame and sucralose, have the potential to remove you from a fasting state." Under 21 CFR 101.60, a zero-calorie claim also allows "less than 5 calories per reference amount customarily consumed." If you are strict, buy the unflavored kind and mix it with plain water.

When should you take creatine if you fast?

Timing is your call, and it is a convenience question as much as anything. The International Society of Sports Nutrition position stand says that once muscle creatine stores are full, they "can generally be maintained" with 3 to 5 grams a day. That is a daily amount, with no fixed hour attached to it in that sentence. It adds that taking creatine with carbohydrate or with carbohydrate and protein has "been reported to more consistently" increase muscle retention. That is one reason to take it with a meal in your eating window.

16:8 with an afternoon workout
  • Fast: 8:00 pm to 12:00 pm.
  • 12:30 pm: first meal, with 5 g creatine in water.
  • Workout at 5:00 pm, and dinner by 8:00 pm.
  • No need to take it during the fast at all.
Morning workout during a fast
  • Fast: 8:00 pm to 12:00 pm.
  • 7:00 am workout. If you want creatine now, use unflavored powder in water.
  • Or wait until your first meal at noon. Both give you the same daily dose.
FastTrack timer with a countdown and the start and target times
A morning fast on FastTrack's timer. The window opens at your target time.

FastTrack keeps track of your window, so you can see at a glance when your eating window opens. The free timers cover 16:8, 18:6 and 20:4.

What the evidence says about creatine

The NIH Office of Dietary Supplements fact sheet says the ISSN "states that creatine monohydrate is the most effective nutritional supplement currently available for enhancing capacity for high-intensity exercise and lean body mass during exercise". It also calls it "of little value for endurance sports". That fact sheet lists "Few safety concerns reported at typical dose", with reported adverse effects including "Weight gain due to water retention" and anecdotal reports of nausea, diarrhea and cramps.

None of that research tested people who were fasting in the way this page discusses. So we can say what creatine is and what it contains, but not how it behaves during a fast.

Water, stomach comfort and body weight

Some people find supplements harder on an empty stomach. If plain creatine in water bothers you during a fast, move it to your eating window, which costs you nothing. Keep your fluids up either way, since a fast takes away the water that comes with meals.

Why the scale may move
  • Start creatine and your weight may rise by a pound or two.
  • The NIH fact sheet lists weight gain due to water retention as a reported effect.
  • If you are also fasting to lose weight, that can look like a setback.
  • Log it, and look at a few weeks, rather than a single morning.

A simple decision guide for creatine and fasting

If you do not want to think about any of this again, one of these three routines will cover you.

  • The no-question routine. Take your creatine with your first meal every day. You never have to wonder whether it broke anything, and you stay consistent.
  • The training routine. Mix plain unflavored creatine with water when you train during your fast. It stays calorie free, as long as the tub lists creatine and nothing else.
  • The flavored routine. If you only enjoy the flavored kind, keep it to your eating window. A flavored powder inside your window has no fasting question at all.
Long fast, 24 hours
  • Last meal at 7:00 pm, and the fast ends at 7:00 pm next day.
  • Daily creatine habit: 5 g.
  • Easiest choice: take it at 7:15 pm with your meal, and keep the same daily dose.
  • Missing an hour or two doesn't change the daily total.

If you take creatine for a medical reason, or have kidney disease

Talk to your clinician first. That applies especially if you have kidney disease, take medication, or are combining creatine with a long fast. A blood test is also a special case: follow the instructions from your lab, and see fasting before blood work. Ask whether to pause creatine before a kidney-function test, since your clinician will want to know that you take it.

Other supplements and drinks

The same method works for anything else: read the label, count the calories, and decide what your rule is. Our guides on coffee and lemon water use it, and what breaks a fast pulls the common ones together. If you are working out your window, the intermittent fasting calculator helps.

FastTrack history listing past fasts with schedule, times and duration
Your past fasts in FastTrack, which you can edit for free.

Questions people ask

Can I take creatine on an empty stomach?

You can, if plain creatine in water sits well with you. If it upsets your stomach, take it with your first meal instead. The ISSN position stand describes a daily amount, so moving it into your eating window is an easy fix.

Do creatine gummies break a fast?

Most likely, since gummies usually contain sugar or sugar alcohols. Check the label on yours. If you want to stay strict, use plain powder in water during the fast, or take the gummies in your eating window.

Is it better to take creatine before or after fasting?

We did not find research comparing this for fasting people. The simplest choice is with your first meal, as the ISSN says taking it with carbohydrate or protein has been reported to improve retention. Consistency every day matters more than the hour.

Does creatine stop autophagy?

We did not find a study that tested this, so we cannot say. Claims in either direction are guesses. If autophagy is your reason for fasting, take creatine in your eating window to avoid the question.

Sources

Guides

  • A 16:8 intermittent fasting scheduleA 16:8 intermittent fasting schedule with clock times for early risers, 9-to-5, night shifts and weekends, a 12:12 ramp-up week and what the evidence says.
  • 18:6 intermittent fasting18:6 intermittent fasting means fasting 18 hours and eating in a 6-hour window. See sample schedules, how it compares to 16:8, and who should avoid it.
  • 20:4 intermittent fasting20:4 intermittent fasting means fasting 20 hours and eating within 4. See sample schedules, how it differs from OMAD, the evidence and who should avoid it.
  • Best foods to break a fastThe best foods to break a fast are ordinary: protein, fiber and whole grains. See three meals with USDA numbers, what to limit and long-fast cautions.
  • Does bone broth break a fast?Does bone broth break a fast? Under a strict rule, yes: it has calories and protein. See USDA figures, how to read a carton, and when to drink it instead.
  • Does coffee break a fast?Does coffee break a fast? An order-by-order table for black coffee, milk, latte, cream, bulletproof and sweeteners, with USDA calories and worked mornings.
  • Does gum break a fast?Does gum break a fast? Sugared gum does, and sugar-free gum is a gray area with a few calories and sweeteners. See the label math and what to use instead.
  • Does lemon water break a fast?Does lemon water break a fast? A wedge is about 1 calorie and a whole lemon about 11. See the USDA table, strict and relaxed rules, and the lab exception.
  • Does stevia break a fast?Does stevia break a fast? Pure stevia has almost no calories, but it is still a gray area and packets often hide fillers. How to read the label and decide.
  • A fasting app without a subscription wallLooking for a fasting app without a subscription? What a free intermittent fasting tracker should include, the traps, and what FastTrack keeps free.
  • Fasting before blood workFasting before blood work: which tests need it, the hours Labcorp, Quest and MedlinePlus give, and seven timelines from your last meal to the draw.
  • Intermittent fasting calculatorA free intermittent fasting calculator: pick 16:8, 18:6, 20:4 or OMAD, enter your last meal, and see when your fast ends and your window opens.
  • Keto and intermittent fastingKeto and intermittent fasting can be combined, but no strong evidence shows it's better. See what each does, a sample day, risks and who should avoid it.
  • OMAD: one meal a dayOMAD means eating one meal a day and fasting 23 hours. What the trial really found, who should avoid it, a sample day and a plate with real numbers.
  • A Simple fasting app alternativeLooking for a Simple fasting app alternative? Compare apps by their own listings, what you give up without a coach, and how to cancel and move across.
  • What breaks a fast?What breaks a fast? Anything with calories, by the strict rule. See one table of drinks, sweeteners and supplements, plus what to do if you slip up.
  • A Zero fasting app alternativeLooking for a Zero fasting app alternative? What Zero includes free and in Zero Plus, by its own App Store listing, next to FastTrack's free tier.